Martha Stewart's unconventional take on the perfect timing for serving Thanksgiving dinner has sparked a heated debate among fans and foodies alike. In her recent appearance on The Today Show, the renowned lifestyle expert suggested that 2 pm be the ideal time to serve Thanksgiving dinner.
According to Stewart, having guests arrive early allows everyone to eat together while also enjoying some light entertainment, such as watching sports games or sipping on drinks before indulging in a late-night dessert extravaganza. This unconventional approach, which deviates from the traditional dinner-only format that many people are accustomed to, has garnered both praise and criticism.
Some viewers have taken issue with Stewart's proposal, citing concerns about cooking time and the logistics of preparing multiple dishes simultaneously. As one commenter pointed out, "Thanksgiving lunch? No thanks. 4 pm at the earliest," while another expressed frustration at being forced into an early dinner schedule, stating that they prefer to enjoy their holiday meal later in the day.
On the other hand, some fans have praised Stewart's unconventional approach, appreciating the flexibility and relaxed atmosphere that comes with having a longer-than-usual celebration. One viewer noted that "12-2 pm is best," citing the benefits of an earlier start time for their own Thanksgiving celebrations.
Stewart also shared her tips and tricks for a stress-free Thanksgiving dinner in her recent episode on The Today Show, including a foolproof recipe for keeping turkey juicy and sharing her go-to dishes for the holiday. Among these was her mother's famous mashed potatoes recipe, which relies on a crucial ingredient that Stewart revealed: cream cheese with butter and milk.
According to Stewart, having guests arrive early allows everyone to eat together while also enjoying some light entertainment, such as watching sports games or sipping on drinks before indulging in a late-night dessert extravaganza. This unconventional approach, which deviates from the traditional dinner-only format that many people are accustomed to, has garnered both praise and criticism.
Some viewers have taken issue with Stewart's proposal, citing concerns about cooking time and the logistics of preparing multiple dishes simultaneously. As one commenter pointed out, "Thanksgiving lunch? No thanks. 4 pm at the earliest," while another expressed frustration at being forced into an early dinner schedule, stating that they prefer to enjoy their holiday meal later in the day.
On the other hand, some fans have praised Stewart's unconventional approach, appreciating the flexibility and relaxed atmosphere that comes with having a longer-than-usual celebration. One viewer noted that "12-2 pm is best," citing the benefits of an earlier start time for their own Thanksgiving celebrations.
Stewart also shared her tips and tricks for a stress-free Thanksgiving dinner in her recent episode on The Today Show, including a foolproof recipe for keeping turkey juicy and sharing her go-to dishes for the holiday. Among these was her mother's famous mashed potatoes recipe, which relies on a crucial ingredient that Stewart revealed: cream cheese with butter and milk.
i mean who needs an early dinner anyway? it sounds like a great excuse to have some pre-feast vibes going on 
but at the same time i can see how it'd be a logistical nightmare for some ppl. my aunt does thanksgiving and she's always stressing about getting everything out on time lol but if you're gonna do it, 2 pm all day is where it's at imo!
. Who says you can't have dessert before dinner, right? I mean, come on, it's the holidays! We should be enjoying ourselves, not rushing through a meal just to fit into some arbitrary schedule. Plus, having some downtime in the afternoon is a great way to recharge after all that cooking and prep work earlier in the day. And let's be real, who doesn't love an excuse to watch sports or have a few drinks before dinner? It's not like it's gonna ruin Thanksgiving for anyone... as long as you're serving up some delicious food (like Stewart's mashed potatoes with cream cheese - yum!)
! Of course, logistics might be a thing for some people, but I think the benefits of an earlier start time far outweigh that. Plus, who needs traditional dinner-only when you can have a whole day (or evening) to celebrate? 
! I love how she's shaking things up and making Thanksgiving dinner about more than just eating... it's all about the vibes 
! Having a 2 pm start time is like, totally doable, especially if you've got a big crew coming over. Plus, who doesn't love a good late-night dessert party? 
But I can see why some peeps might be like "no thanks" and want to stick to the traditional schedule 
. Maybe Martha could do a post about how to prep ahead of time to make it work for those who are skeptical? 
But seriously, have you ever tried serving dinner at that time? It's like trying to eat a whole pizza by yourself in one sitting...not easy 
. And what about the food coma? I'm good with my 4 pm turkey dinner party, thanks 
. Although, Martha's mashed potatoes recipe sounds pretty darn good! Cream cheese with butter and milk, yeah that's a winner 
. Maybe we can start calling it "Thanksgiving at Martha's" instead of just Thanksgiving 
. Plus, an earlier start time means less time for relaxation and entertainment before dinner. I think Martha should've just suggested a more realistic timeline 
.
2 pm dinner? I'm low-key Team Martha on this one, fam! I mean, who says you gotta be glued to the table at 4 pm or whenever "tradition" dictates? Having some chill vibes before the main event is EVERYTHING. Plus, can you even imagine how less stressed everyone would be if they could just relax and enjoy each other's company for a bit before the big feast? My mom used to do this on Thanksgiving, and it was always so much fun! I might not have her famous mashed potatoes recipe (I'm more of a butter-to-milk ratio experiment kinda gal), but I'm def feeling Martha's vibe. Bring on the 12-2 pm celebration vibes 
. And what about those who want to take a nap after dinner? 2 pm is still way too early for that 
. Do whatever works best for you, whether that's eating at 2 pm or 4 pm or even later! It's not about the time, it's about sharing a delicious meal together 
