Mature decision to deny Manchester City a penalty for handball sets example for referees | Chris Foy

C

Clumsy Cow

Top Referees Embrace New Handball Rules as Consistency Gains Ground

Former Premier League referee Chris Foy has praised the increasing maturity among referees in interpreting handball rules, citing recent examples that demonstrate a clear and consistent approach. The International Football Association Board (IFAB) has introduced several law changes in an effort to achieve consistent outcomes, but varying interpretations have remained a topic of discussion.

One notable instance was during Manchester United's match against Arsenal, where referee Craig Pawson made the correct decision not to award a penalty for a potential handball by Harry Maguire. The incident involved Maguire's outstretched arm blocking Mikel Merino's shot as he attempted to challenge for the ball on the ground.

The VAR review confirmed Pawson's initial assessment, and Foy agrees that it was a justified call, pointing out that Maguire's arm was not unnaturally positioned or "bigger" than usual. The experience highlights how referees are becoming more adept at applying handball laws consistently.

In contrast, other incidents have been subject to differing interpretations. During Crystal Palace's match against Chelsea, referee Darren England awarded a penalty for a potential handball by Jaydee Canvot, despite the VAR indicating otherwise. However, Foy notes that this decision may not reflect the more common approach in the Premier League, where referees are now taking a more nuanced view.

The Professional Game Match Officials (PGMO) development group has played a significant role in promoting these new guidelines, with first-year referee Farai Hallam demonstrating a sound understanding of handball laws during his debut match against Manchester City. When a potential handball by Yerson Mosquera was flagged for review by the VAR, Hallam remained committed to his initial decision and took the time to consider the evidence.

Foy's comments underscore the growth in maturity among referees as they continue to navigate the complexities of handball laws. As he noted, while it is essential to be clear about when a handball should be awarded, there are situations where interpretation becomes necessary. Nonetheless, his endorsement of referees' increasing consistency in applying these laws suggests a brighter future for the sport.

As one might expect from someone who officiated professional football for 25 years, Foy's stance on this matter is rooted in a desire to see handballs clearly defined and consistently applied. However, even he acknowledges that there will be instances where players may appeal for handball despite it being clear-cut – and here, his willingness to temper expectations highlights the challenges of striking the perfect balance between clarity and nuance.

The Premier League's approach to handling handball has come a long way in recent years, with PGMO's emphasis on high-threshold standards contributing significantly to this development.
 
I'm so stoked that refs are finally getting it right when it comes to handball calls 🙌! I mean, it's all about consistency and being clear about when you should award a pen. But at the same time, I get why Foy says there needs to be room for nuance – sometimes players will just do stupid stuff and try to get on their teammates' heads 😂. The Premier League is doing a great job of promoting these new guidelines and getting refs up to speed on handball laws. It's not always easy, but it's clear that they're making progress 👍. I'm loving the fact that we're seeing more mature decision-making from referees – it's all about finding that balance between being strict and being fair 🤔.
 
just got word that the world economy is still in shambles after all those global trade deals went south 🤕 inflation's still creeping up and people are losing their jobs left and right 💸 no wonder the premier league is trying to get its handball rules straight, at least there we can expect some consistency 😅
 
🚨🏆 New rules in Handball are kinda cool I guess... Refs finally start to get it right 🙏 Consistency is key, but sometimes u gotta use ur brain lol. Heard from Chris Foy that referees r becoming more mature & taking the time 2 think thru situations. Some ppl might still try 2 appeal 4 handballs tho 😂 PGMO's work is really payin off though! We'll c how it all plays out, prob some awesome matches ahead 🏈
 
🤝 I totally get what Chris Foy is saying now - consistency is key when it comes to handball rules, and referees are finally starting to nail it 🎯. I mean, those two examples from Manchester United and Arsenal vs Crystal Palace were spot on, no debate needed 💯. And you're right, there will always be some grey areas where players might try to milk the ref for a handball 😒, but at least now we know what's expected.

But I do think it's awesome that referees like Farai Hallam are being given the time and space to make decisions - sometimes VAR can just add unnecessary drama 📺. And Foy's right, clarity is still super important, but nuance is too 😊. It's all about finding that balance so we don't over-complicate things.

And yep, PGMO's been doing some great work here 👏. They've got to keep pushing for those high standards and getting the message out there 📢. Can't wait to see how this all plays out in the future 🤞!
 
I'm loving how the refs are getting better at calling those handball decisions 🤩! It's about time we saw some consistency in the Premier League. I remember when you'd get all these differing opinions and it would be like, 'what's going on?!' 😂 But now, it seems like they're taking a more nuanced approach and that's really cool to see.

I mean, take that Manchester United vs Arsenal game for example - it was a clear-cut call but some people were still questioning it. Now, with VAR and all that, we can finally get some consistency in the sport. And it's not just about the big calls either, it's the smaller ones too, like when a ref is unsure if it's a handball or not.

The PGMO group has done an amazing job promoting these new guidelines and I'm glad to see first-year refs like Farai Hallam getting in on the action 🎉. It's all about finding that balance between being clear and nuanced, and I think we're finally getting there. Now, let's keep it up and enjoy some more great games with consistent refereeing 👏!
 
omg i just watched that game where maguire blocked mikel merino's shot and i was like is he gonna get away with it lol 🤣 but then the ref said nope and the var confirmed it so that's cool i guess handball laws can be pretty tricky but it's good to hear that refs are getting better at it 💪
 
I'm so glad to see refs finally getting it right! 🙌 The new rules are really helping them understand when to award a penalty and when not to. It's all about consistency now, and I love how they're being more nuanced in their decisions. Farai Hallam is a great example of this - he stayed calm under pressure and didn't waver from his decision 😎. Of course, there will always be some weird ones where players try to get away with it, but at least we know the refs are on top of it now 💪.
 
I think it's dope that referees are getting better at making those handball calls 🤔👍. It's not just about being clear-cut, but also knowing when to trust your instincts and consider the context of the game. The PGMO group is doing a great job in promoting these new guidelines, and it's awesome to see refs like Farai Hallam showing that they can handle it 💯. Still, gotta acknowledge that there'll be times when players will appeal for handball even if it's not clearly out 🤷‍♂️. Overall, I'm hyped about the direction this is headed 👌
 
🤔 I think it's awesome that top referees like Chris Foy are embracing the new handball rules 🙌! The Premier League is really making progress here, and it's not just about getting the rules right, but also about being consistent with their decisions ⏰. I mean, who doesn't love a clear cut decision when it comes to something as crucial as a penalty? 🤦‍♂️ It's great to see that referees are becoming more mature in interpreting these laws, and it's definitely helping to reduce the number of disputed calls 📉.

What I find really interesting is how PGMO's emphasis on high-threshold standards has helped to raise the bar for referees 👏. It's not just about following the rules, but also about understanding the nuances of the game 💡. And it's fantastic to see young referees like Farai Hallam coming through and showing a great grasp of these laws 🎉. The future of handball looks bright, and I'm excited to see how this continues to evolve in the years to come 🔜.

One thing that does concern me is that even with more consistency comes some uncertainty 🤔. Will we still have players trying to appeal for handballs despite it being clear-cut? 🤷‍♂️ Only time will tell, but I think Foy's willingness to temper expectations shows he gets it 💡. Let's keep supporting these referees and the efforts they're putting in to make this game more fair and enjoyable for everyone 😊! 👍
 
🤩 think its awesome how referees are getting better at applying those new handball rules 🙌 its like they're finally starting to get it right 🎯 i mean, dont get me wrong, there will always be some calls that go against us but overall im hyped for the direction the premier league is heading 💪
 
I'm loving how referees are getting better at calling handballs 🙌. I've seen some crazy calls over the years, but it's awesome to see them getting more consistent. I mean, that Maguire incident with Manchester United vs Arsenal? Spot on by Craig Pawson! The VAR review confirmed it was a fair call and not just some weird positioning going on 😂. Now, I'm not saying it's always gonna be clear-cut, but it's great to see refs taking the time to think about it and not just throwing a red card at everyone 🙄. Farai Hallam looks like a top young ref too 👍, and the PGMO's helping to promote those new guidelines 🤝. Can't wait to see how this develops! 💪
 
I'm so glad to see refs finally getting it right! 🙌 I mean, who doesn't love watching a clear-cut handball get ignored? 😂 It's like they're becoming more intelligent and less reliant on VAR 😅. Remember when ref Darren England awarded that penalty for Jaydee Canvot's "potential" handball? 🤣 I was like, mate, that was a dodgy decision at best! But seriously, it's awesome to see the growth in maturity among refs, especially with PGMO promoting these new guidelines. Farai Hallam looks like a star in the making 👍!
 
the latest changes to handball rules are actually kinda cool, I guess 🤷‍♂️ at least now refs aren't so inconsistent about it, but foy's right that there'll still be some gray areas where things get murky 🔮 like when you're not entirely sure if the arm was outstretched or what 🤔 i mean, i'm glad to see pgmo pushing for these new guidelines tho, they've definitely helped raise the bar for refs
 
🤔 I'm loving how the Premier League is finally getting its act together when it comes to the handball rules. It's about time we saw some consistency from the refs, and now that they're taking a more nuanced approach, I think it'll be awesome to see fewer disputes on the pitch 🏈.

I mean, take that incident with Maguire vs Arsenal - if you watch the replay, Pawson's call was spot on. It's not like he was over-reacting or anything 😂. And yeah, some of the other refs might have gotten it wrong, but at least they're learning from their mistakes and trying to do better 🤝.

I've been watching a lot of matches lately and I gotta say, I'm impressed by how much progress has been made in terms of refereeing standards. Even Foy, who's seen it all, is acknowledging that there's still room for improvement 💡. Maybe we'll see even more advanced VAR technology in the future? That would be a game-changer 📺.

But you know what the best part is? It's not just about winning or losing - it's about the fans having a better experience overall 😊. When the refs are consistent and clear, everyone wins 🎉. So here's to more clarity on handball rules and an even more enjoyable Premier League season! 🍺
 
"You can't separate the process from the product" 🤔💡. Referees are getting better at understanding and applying the new handball rules, but there's still room for improvement. It's like trying to find that perfect balance between too much guidance and not enough trust in the officials' judgment. The Premier League is moving in the right direction with PGMO's high-threshold standards, but it's up to the referees to keep pushing themselves to get even better at calling those handball decisions.
 
I think its kinda cool that referees are getting better at making calls on handballs. Like the Manchester United vs Arsenal game where Chris Foy was saying that referee Craig Pawson made the right call not giving a pen even tho Maguire's arm looked suspicious lol I mean you need some judgment in those situations. But seriously PGMO is doing a good job promoting new guidelines and its great to see refs like Farai Hallam who seem to be on top of handball laws 🤔
 
🤔 This new handball rule thing is looking up 🌞, but there's still some wiggle room for human error 😅. Refs are getting better at sticking to the rules, but it's not like they're infallible 💯. Still, at least the VAR is helping to keep everyone in check 👀. Can't wait to see how this plays out over the next few seasons 🏟️
 
🤔 "You can't go back and change the beginning, but you can start where you are and change the ending." - C.S. Lewis

The introduction of new handball rules is definitely a step in the right direction for consistency. It's refreshing to see referees like Farai Hallam taking the time to consider the evidence and making sound decisions. The Premier League has come a long way in handling handballs, but there's still room for improvement. It's not just about applying the rules correctly, but also about understanding the nuances of each situation.

👏 "The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams." - Eleanor Roosevelt
 
idk why ppl think the new handball rules r gonna make a huge diff it's all still subjective 😒 referees r just tryna be cool n fit in w/ the times but at the end of the day its still about how u interpret it 25 yrs on from when Foy started officiating, dont expect him 2 change his mind anytime soon 🙄
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top