Canada's Prime Minister Mark Carney has unveiled a multibillion-dollar investment package aimed at boosting the country's competitiveness, but critics argue that his "nation-building" programme falls short on its promise to transform Canada for the better.
The $56 billion plan includes a string of resource-based projects such as mines and natural gas exports, which will supposedly position Canada as an energy superpower. However, experts say that these initiatives largely favour the existing economic status quo, neglecting projects that could have a more significant impact on everyday Canadians' lives.
"We're investing in being a resource economy," said Shoshanna Saxe, a professor of civil engineering at the University of Toronto. "And I don't think that's wrong, but it feels like we're missing an opportunity to invest in something new and forward-looking."
Carney's government has opted to prioritize projects with faster returns over those that could lead to more transformative changes. For instance, the proposed power line in British Columbia is expected to secure significant private sector investments, but critics argue that similar infrastructure upgrades are desperately needed elsewhere.
"The signal the government is sending is that Canada is a resource economy," Saxe noted. "And I don't think that's wrong, but it feels like we're not pushing hard enough on what could be game-changers."
One area where Carney's programme falls short is in addressing Canada's infrastructure deficit. With significant gaps in water systems, bridges, public transit, and housing, the prime minister's focus on resource extraction seems out of touch with the everyday concerns of Canadians.
"We're not asking you to engage in changing the basic way Canada works," Saxe said. "We're saying we're going to continue to invest in the old strengths of Canada. But you're still left wondering what is possible."
The lack of investment in these critical areas raises questions about Carney's commitment to creating a more sustainable and equitable future for Canadians. While his government touts its nation-building programme as transformative, many experts believe that it fails to address the pressing needs of the country.
The $56 billion plan includes a string of resource-based projects such as mines and natural gas exports, which will supposedly position Canada as an energy superpower. However, experts say that these initiatives largely favour the existing economic status quo, neglecting projects that could have a more significant impact on everyday Canadians' lives.
"We're investing in being a resource economy," said Shoshanna Saxe, a professor of civil engineering at the University of Toronto. "And I don't think that's wrong, but it feels like we're missing an opportunity to invest in something new and forward-looking."
Carney's government has opted to prioritize projects with faster returns over those that could lead to more transformative changes. For instance, the proposed power line in British Columbia is expected to secure significant private sector investments, but critics argue that similar infrastructure upgrades are desperately needed elsewhere.
"The signal the government is sending is that Canada is a resource economy," Saxe noted. "And I don't think that's wrong, but it feels like we're not pushing hard enough on what could be game-changers."
One area where Carney's programme falls short is in addressing Canada's infrastructure deficit. With significant gaps in water systems, bridges, public transit, and housing, the prime minister's focus on resource extraction seems out of touch with the everyday concerns of Canadians.
"We're not asking you to engage in changing the basic way Canada works," Saxe said. "We're saying we're going to continue to invest in the old strengths of Canada. But you're still left wondering what is possible."
The lack of investment in these critical areas raises questions about Carney's commitment to creating a more sustainable and equitable future for Canadians. While his government touts its nation-building programme as transformative, many experts believe that it fails to address the pressing needs of the country.
. Investing in resource extraction is great and all, but what about the people who are struggling with basic infrastructure? It's like, we need to upgrade our water systems, bridges, and public transit ASAP 
, but Carney's focus is on becoming an energy superpower... I mean, I get it, energy is important, but at what cost? 
We can't just keep playing catch-up when it comes to our infrastructure. It's like, we're already behind in so many areas, and now we're prioritizing the things that are going to make us money over the things that will really improve people's lives 
. I wish Carney would think outside the box and invest in some real game-changers 
.
. We need more than just a nation-building programme that only benefits the status quo, we need real change 
.
. They're basically playing it safe and investing in stuff that's gonna give them a quick win, but not necessarily have a lasting impact 
. Meanwhile, everyday Canadians are still dealing with some serious infrastructure issues like broken water systems and housing shortages 
. The fact that they're prioritizing resource extraction over infrastructure upgrades and everyday Canadians' needs feels like a whole lot of window dressing 
. It's all about lining the pockets of the powerful interests instead of actually making a real difference in people's lives 
He's putting all his eggs in resource-based projects, which are kinda cool, but what about the everyday people? 
Canadians need better water systems, bridges, public transit, and affordable housing! 
That's where the real game-changers are. It feels like he's just touting more of the same old stuff instead of pushing for big changes 
.
. Can't we think outside the box for once? 
And what about all the young kids who can't access quality education or affordable housing? It's all about finding that balance between progress and people's needs 
