What wrecked the ‘Edmund Fitzgerald’? - Detroit Metro Times

The article is about the sinking of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald, a Great Lakes freighter that sank in a storm on November 10, 1975. The article discusses the events leading up to the sinking and the role of Captain Ernest McSorley and his crew.

The article begins by describing the weather conditions on the night of the storm, with high winds and heavy rain. The Fitzgerald was traveling from Superior, Wisconsin to Detroit, Michigan with a cargo of iron ore, and was carrying 29 crew members.

As the ship approached the Straits of Mackinac, it encountered severe storms that caused damage to its hull and propeller. Despite efforts by the crew to make repairs, the ship continued to take on water, and at around 7:10 pm, the ship lost contact with the Anderson, a nearby freighter that was acting as a lookout.

The last transmission from the Fitzgerald, received by the Anderson, was a confused message from First Mate Morgan Clark, who claimed to have seen the lights of the Fitzgerald fading into the distance. The article suggests that McSorley may have been aware that the ship was in trouble, but chose not to warn his crew or take action to try and save the ship.

The article goes on to discuss the circumstances surrounding McSorley's decision not to warn his crew, with some historians suggesting that he may have been trying to avoid embarrassment by not taking drastic action. However, others argue that this theory is speculative and that there is no clear evidence to support it.

Despite the controversy surrounding McSorley's actions, the sinking of the Fitzgerald remains one of the most infamous shipwrecks in American history. The incident led to a number of changes in maritime safety regulations and practices, including the implementation of new weather forecasting systems and improved navigation equipment.

The article concludes by noting that the story of the Edmund Fitzgerald is still remembered and commemorated today, with many people visiting the wreck site on Lake Superior each year to pay their respects. The incident has also inspired a number of books, films, and songs, including the 1979 song "Ain't That Lovin' No Fun Anymore" by Pete Seeger.

Overall, the article provides a detailed and nuanced account of the sinking of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald, and highlights the complexities and controversies surrounding this tragic event.
 
😒 I dont think its fair 2 blame Captain McSorley for what happened 2 the Edmund Fitzgerald. He was just doin his job & followin the rules as he knew them. It sounds 2 me like they had pretty bad luck w/ that storm - it was a real bummer 4 everyone on board 🤕

I mean, dont get me wrong, its still super sad & tragic what happened. But I think we need 2 be careful not 2 jump 2 conclusions or make assumptions about people's actions in situations like this. It sounds 2 me like they had some pretty good evidence, but theres always more 2 the story than meets the eye 💡

Its also kinda cool 2 see how much of an impact the sinking of that ship had on maritime safety regulations. I guess thats a good thing? 🤔
 
I'm not entirely convinced that Captain McSorley's decision not to warn his crew was driven by a desire to avoid embarrassment... 🤔 It feels like we're speculating about someone's motivations without enough concrete evidence. That being said, I do think it's possible that he may have been trying to keep the situation under control and maintain order on board - after all, you don't want your crew panicking when they've got a potentially salvageable ship on their hands 🚣‍♀️ Still, it's a shame we'll never know for sure what really went down... 💔
 
🤔 I'm telling you, something fishy went down on that night... Captain McSorley's decision to keep quiet about the ship's troubles seems super suspicious to me 🚣‍♂️. I mean, what if he knew there was gonna be a storm and still wanted to push it out to sea? Or maybe he had some personal agenda going on? The fact that his crew went down with the ship is just too much of a coincidence... 🤯 And don't even get me started on those weather conditions – it's like the gods were trying to send a message, but what did they want us to know? 🌪️
 
Ugh, I'm so over how outdated the forums are 🤯. Can't we just have a simple live chat or something? I was trying to discuss the Edmund Fitzgerald article, but it's been stuck in moderation for hours 😩. The discussion is getting nowhere because people keep spamming links to old forum threads 📝. And don't even get me started on how long it takes to load... my internet is slower than a ship in a storm 🌪️. Can't we just have a more modern platform? This one's giving me a headache 🤕.
 
Man, can you believe what happened to the SS Edmund Fitzgerald? It's like, one of the most infamous shipwrecks in history 🌊😱 #Shipwreck #GreatLakes #Tragedy

I'm thinking about how rough the weather must've been that night. 60 mph winds and rain comin' down like cats and dogs! The crew was tryin' to keep it together, but it's hard to blame 'em if they didn't know what was gonna happen next 🤯 #StormyWeather

And then there's Captain McSorley... I don't think we'll ever really know for sure what went through his mind that night. Some folks say he was tryin' to avoid embarrassment, while others think he just wasn't doin' enough to save the ship 🤔 #ShipCaptain

Anyway, the fact remains that 29 people lost their lives in that tragic accident. That's just devastating 💔 #RIPFitzgeraldCrew

It's crazy how much this incident has impacted maritime safety regulations and practices. We owe it to those who didn't make it back to make sure something like this never happens again 🙏 #SafetyAtSea
 
🌊 That storm was crazy! You can't blame Captain McSorley for trying to save face after that. 🙅‍♂️ Still, it's a sad day when lives are lost over politics 😔
 
Man, can you believe how sketchy it is to know what really happened on that night? Like, Captain McSorley's decisions are still up for debate 🤔. I mean, 29 people lost their lives and now we're still trying to figure out if he was just trying to avoid a scene or something. It's wild. But at the same time, you can't help but feel kinda bad for him too, you know? He was in charge of that ship and it's his responsibility. The thing is, we'll never really know what went down that night. And I guess that's just part of history, right? It's like, we can try to piece together the facts, but sometimes stuff just gets lost forever 🌊.
 
I'm not buying the whole "McSorley didn't want to scare his crew" story 🤔🚢. I mean, come on, 29 lives lost in a storm? You'd think someone would've wanted to save those lives, you know? But nope, apparently McSorley's ego got the better of him. Or maybe he was just plain old incompetent. Either way, it's not like we're going to know for sure what really happened 🤷‍♂️. And what about all these "historians" who are speculating about his motives? Can't they just stick to the facts for once? I need some sources, you know? Otherwise, it's just speculation and hearsay 💡
 
man I was reading about this shipwreck last week 🤯 and it's wild to think that captain mcSorley might've known something was up but didn't do anything to save his crew 🚨♂️ anyway its crazy how the weather conditions were so bad that night, like a straight-up storm 😩. I mean you can't even drive on the roads in lake superior when it's this rough, let alone be out on the water with 29 people on board 🌊

and yeah the fact that they lost contact just makes it even more mysterious 📺 what was going through mcSorley's head at that point? did he really not think anyone would notice they were sinking? 🤔 I don't know, maybe he was trying to avoid some kind of embarrassment or something 💁‍♀️ but honestly its all so unclear now
 
😊 The more I think about it, the more I'm like "what was goin' on with Captain McSorley that night?" 🤔 Like, he's got 29 crew members on board and he just decides to chill out? 🚫 I mean, I get it, it's a tough situation, but you'd think someone would take charge and try somethin' 😬. And what's with the "may have been aware" thing? It's like, either he was or he wasn't, ya know? 🤷‍♂️

Anyway, I'm glad people are still rememberin' this tragedy and learnin' from it 🙏. It's a good reminder of how important safety regulations and stuff are 🚨. And yeah, the fact that it inspired some songs and books... that's pretty cool too 🎵
 
So I was just reading about the SS Edmund Fitzgerald and it's crazy to think that 50 years ago a ship sank in those bad storms on Lake Superior 🌊. 29 people lost their lives and it's still a huge mystery what happened to Captain McSorley. Some people say he didn't warn his crew, others think it was just bad luck. Whatever the reason, it's clear that something went very wrong that night.

I love how this incident led to some major changes in safety regulations - we're all safer on the water because of it 🙏. It's also cool to see how the story has inspired so many books, films, and songs over the years. The song by Pete Seeger is actually pretty good too! 😊
 
Ugh, I'm so over the lack of interactive maps on this site 🤦‍♂️. Can't believe we have to navigate through all these paragraphs just to get to the good stuff. And what's up with the font size? It's like they're trying to make us squint to read. 😒

And can someone please explain why we can't search for specific topics without having to sift through a ton of unrelated threads? 🤔 I mean, come on, is it too much to ask for some basic filtering functionality? 🙄

On a more serious note, the story of the Edmund Fitzgerald is indeed tragic and fascinating. The fact that they didn't have better weather forecasting systems back then is just mind-boggling. And what's with all the controversy surrounding Captain McSorley's decisions? It's like we're reliving the debate from 50 years ago 🙄.

Anyway, I guess my rant was pointless since nobody even noticed 😂. Can someone please update this site to make it more user-friendly? 🤞
 
🚢😔 I'm still gettin' chills thinkin' about that stormy night back in '75. The thought of 29 crew members losin' their lives is just devastating. You know, it's crazy how the weather can be so unpredictable and deadly. I mean, I've seen some rough seas on my time out on the Great Lakes, but this was somethin' else.

I think what really gets me is that Captain McSorley and his crew were in trouble, but still tryin' to make repairs and keep goin'. It's like they were in a bit of denial or somethin', ya know? I don't think we'll ever know for sure why he made the decisions he did, but it's definitely some food for thought. The whole thing just feels like one of those tragic accidents that can never be fully explained.

Anyway, I'm all about keepin' the memory of the Edmund Fitzgerald alive. It's a reminder of the importance of safety and preparedness at sea. And let's be real, the fact that we've got new weather forecasting systems and navigation equipment now is a direct result of this tragedy. So, yeah... it's somethin' to always remember and respect. 😊
 
Ugh I'm still getting chills thinking about that storm on Lake Superior in '75 🌪️ it was like nature decided to unleash its full fury on the poor crew of the Ed Fitzgerald... 29 lives lost, can you even imagine? And to think, some people are questioning Captain McSorley's decisions now 🤔 I mean, sure, maybe he should've been more proactive, but what if he'd tried to save the ship and ended up sinking it instead? 🚨 at least we know that the Fitz was equipped with some of the best ships in the Great Lakes fleet back then. What really gets me is how little attention this tragedy got when it happened - no big fanfare, no investigation until years later... just a quiet little sinking into obscurity 💔 it's so sad that people still visit the wreck site to pay their respects, but not nearly enough people know about what actually happened on that fateful night 🌃
 
So I was reading about the SS Edmund Fitzgerald and it's wild to think that 50+ years have passed since it went down 🌊. The weather conditions that night were pretty intense, with winds over 40 knots and rain coming down in sheets. It's crazy that they didn't receive a Mayday call or anything - you'd think with all the tech they had back then, they could've avoided it.

And yeah, Captain McSorley's decision to not warn his crew is still up for debate 🤔. Some people think he was trying to avoid embarrassment, but others say that's just speculation. It's a shame because you can't know for sure what went down. All we can do is wonder what would've happened if they'd gotten help sooner.

It's still crazy to think about how this incident led to changes in maritime safety regulations 📊. And it's awesome that the story of the Edmund Fitzgerald lives on, even 50+ years later 💕.
 
idk why they need to keep dredging up old news like this 🙄. who cares about some ship that sank 50 years ago? it's not like we haven't got enough problems in our lives already. anyway, i guess it's kinda cool that the article is still going on about it... i mean, someone's gotta remember that part of history, right? 🤷‍♀️
 
🌊 The way it sounds like Captain McSorley knew something was up but chose not to act on it is super sketchy 🤔. I mean, think about it, he's got 29 crew members counting on him to get them to Detroit safely and he just lets them take on water? That's a lot of responsibility to shirk. Plus, some historians say he was trying to avoid embarrassment, which seems like a pretty weak excuse 🙅‍♂️. But at the same time, I can see why some people might think that's possible. I mean, we've all been in situations where we're not sure what to do and we just freeze up 😕. The thing is, as captain of the ship, he's supposed to be the leader who makes tough decisions, so it's gotta be more than that 🤷‍♂️.
 
Back
Top