Premier League's warped economics make £65m fee for Semenyo a snip | Jonathan Wilson

Manchester City's £65m move for Bournemouth's Antoine Semenyo has left many scratching their heads, particularly given the fee itself. At first glance, it may seem puzzling why Pep Guardiola's side would shell out such a large sum for a 25-year-old Ghanaian midfielder, especially when Rayan Cherki and Phil Foden have proven to be capable alternatives on the right flank.

However, in an era where the congested Premier League schedule necessitates having flexible squads, City may believe they require Semenyo's unique blend of speed, skill, intelligence, and work ethic. With four-and-a-half years still left on his contract, it's not unreasonable that he commands a fee in excess of £65m - a sum that would place him among the top 25 most expensive signings in Premier League history.

The market dictates value, and if one club is willing to pay such a hefty sum for Semenyo, then so be it. It's also worth noting that this isn't the first time a player has been overvalued due to market sentiment; players like Nordi Mukiele, who was signed by Sunderland from Paris Saint-Germain for significantly less than Semenyo, are often overlooked.

The recent trend of big No 9s in football is another factor at play. The likes of Benjamin Sesko and Hugo Ekitiké have failed to live up to expectations, while players like Erling Haaland have defied the odds by thriving despite not conforming to traditional striker archetypes. It's a complex landscape, but ultimately, goals are what matter most in football.

So, will Semenyo prove to be worth £65m? That's a tough question to answer, as value is subjective and influenced by individual perspectives. In the Premier League, fees have become detached from objective reality, making it difficult to discern true value. One thing is certain, however: Guardiola will undoubtedly have a plan for Semenyo, and his track record of success may hold the key to unlocking the Ghanaian's potential.
 
65m for Semenyo? That's like paying 65p for a pint down at the pub! I'm not saying he's overpriced or anything, but Pep's got some magic dust in his pocket, right? I mean, Rayan and Phil are there, but what if Antoine is the missing piece of the City puzzle? We'll just have to wait and see if he's worth every penny... or a few thousand pounds.
 
I dont think its about overpaying or undervaluing ppl, its about what ur team needs rn 💡 Manchester City has got some decent young talent on the bench, but their first 11 is pretty stacked 🤯 Semenyo might be exactly the kinda player that gives them an edge in games when the big guns are tired 🏃‍♂️
 
🤔 £65m for Antoine Semenyo? It's mental! 🤑 I get why City would want him, though - he's got that special sauce 🔮. His speed and skill are top-notch, and his work ethic is off the charts ⚡️. But £65m? That's just wild west 🤠. What if he doesn't live up to expectations? 💔 Will it be worth it for City? Only time will tell... ⏰.

I'm loving this trend of big No 9s, though! 😁 It shows that goals are what matter most - not just about the stats or the money 🤑. Players like Haaland are proof that you can make it work if you're different from the norm 🌈. I'm curious to see how Semenyo fits into City's plans... will he be the next big thing? ⭐
 
I don't get why they're shelling out so much cash for this guy... I mean, Rayan Cherki's been doing just fine on the right flank since he was a kid 🤔... but you know what? If Pep thinks Semenyo's got what it takes, who am I to argue? 😊 It's all about having flexible squads when the schedule gets crazy, and if Antoine can bring that speed and skill to the table, then yeah, £65m ain't too bad 💸... the market does dictate value, but sometimes you just gotta follow your gut, right? 🤷‍♂️ And hey, at least it's not like they're breaking out the big guns or anything 😅.
 
I mean, come on... £65m for Antoine Semenyo? Are you kiddin' me? He's no Haaland! I get what City's tryin' to do with their squad, but this is just plain crazy talk 🤣. They're not even playin' Cherki and Foden right now, so what makes 'em think they need Semenyo? And don't even get me started on the market value thing... it's all just a bunch of hype, if you ask me 😂. I'm sure Pep's got some genius plan cookin', but I wouldn't put my money on this one 💸.
 
😂🤯 I'm low-key hyped about this signing lol! £65m might seem crazy but Pep's got a way with players, you feel? 🤑 He's always spotting hidden gems and getting them to click. And let's be real, if Cherki & Foden are doing well on the right flank, why not try something new? 🔥 Semenyo's speed & skill combo is intriguing, might just bring some fresh legs to City. 💪 Only time'll tell if it's a wise investment but I trust Pep's vision 🎯
 
omg £65m for semenyo lol what's next £100m for a winger? 🤣 seriously tho, i think pep knows what he's doing, ppl always sayin he's overpayin but his teams are always so dominant. also, semenyo's got skills, don't @ me, i've seen him play and he's quick as hell 🔥. yeah the market is wild rn but if city wants him they should pay up. it's not like semenyo's gonna join a mid-table team for a fraction of that price lol
 
I'm so confused about this Semenyo move 🤔, £65m feels like way too much for me. Pep needs to prove he can make it work, I mean, Rayan Cherki and Phil Foden are solid players, why break the bank? 😐 But at the same time, you gotta respect the market, if City wants him that bad, who am I to argue? 💸 And with all these big-name strikers flopping, maybe Semenyo's the real deal. We'll just have to wait and see how it plays out 🕰️
 
I'm so down for this move 🤩! I mean, Pep has a way of getting the most out of his players, and if he thinks Semenyo can bring that unique energy to the team, I trust him completely 💯. And let's be real, £65m might seem steep, but it's not like City are just shelling out money for the sake of it - they're investing in a player who could make a real difference on the pitch 🏆. Plus, it's not like we haven't seen bigger fees before... like that Sunderland guy Mukiele who got snatched up for a fraction of the cost 💸. So yeah, I'm all for Semenyo and I hope he lives up to his potential 🔥!
 
I dunno about this £65m fee... seems like a whole lotta cash for just a midfielder 🤑. But you're right, in today's Premier League, teams need flexible squads and players who can fit in many roles. Semenyo's got some unique skills that might be worth it... but then again, there are other players out there who do the same thing and get signed for way less 💸. The market's wild, and sometimes players get overhyped 🤯. I'm excited to see how Pep Guardiola plans to use Semenyo, 'cause he's definitely got a track record of making magic happen on the pitch ✨.
 
idk why ppl r surprised its 65m tho semenyo's been hype since he was a teen 🤑 think about all the other 25-30 year olds getting paid silly amounts just cuz they're in demand... meanwhile, semenyo's still got a decent contract left on & pep guardiola's proven track record is pretty solid 🤔
 
I don’t usually comment but I think this transfer move is actually kinda interesting 🤔. £65m seems crazy, but you're right that market value dictates a lot in football. It's not like City is trying to prove a point or anything. They're just looking for the best talent they can get, and if Semenyo fits their system, then I guess it's worth the investment 💸. I mean, we've seen this before with other big signings that didn't exactly pan out 🤦‍♂️. But Pep's got a track record of getting the most out of his players, so maybe he'll be the one to unlock Semenyo's potential 🔓.
 
I'm still trying to wrap my head around this transfer fee 😂. I mean, £65m for Antoine Semenyo is just crazy talk! I get what Pep Guardiola sees in him, but four-and-a-half years left on his contract and a price tag like that? It's just too much to handle, you know? 🤯

I remember when Rayan Cherki and Phil Foden were signed, and everyone was all about how they could fill the right flank, but now we're shelling out £65m for Semenyo, who's basically a similar player... I don't get it 😒. And what about the market, huh? It seems like some players are just getting overvalued due to hype or the pressure of being part of Manchester City's squad 🤔.

It'll be interesting to see if Semenyo lives up to the hype and proves himself as worth £65m 💸. Guardiola's track record is undeniable, but even he can't guarantee results... we'll just have to wait and see how this one plays out!
 
I mean £65m for Antoine Semenyo? That's like saying I'm gonna buy my couch just 'cause it's on sale 🛋️. But seriously, Pep Guardiola's gotta know what he's doing, right? Like when you're buying avocado toast, you don't just grab the fanciest bread because everyone else is 🥑. But for real, Semenyo might just be that special bread – we'll see how it all comes together in the end... or if City just got taken for a ride 😂
 
idk about this one...£65m seems way too much to me lol 🤑 i mean semenyo's got skills but he's not exactly breaking records on the pitch yet. plus there's always a chance he might get injured or just not click with pep's team. what do u think?
 
I mean, you gotta wonder if City are getting a bit carried away with their squad overhaul 🤔. £65m for Semenyo is just wild. I get why they might think he'd be useful given the schedule and all, but have they seen Cherki and Foden in action? They're not half bad! 😂

And yeah, market value can be pretty skewed sometimes. Like, who's to say what a player's worth? It's all just a bunch of numbers and opinions 📊.

I'm intrigued by the whole No 9s trend, though. It's like football is getting all experimental with its strikers. I mean, Haaland's not your typical striker, but he works! 👍

Anyway, only time'll tell if Semenyo lives up to the hype or ends up a flop 💸. One thing's for sure, Pep's got some tricks up his sleeve 🤫.
 
idk about this one, £65m seems like a lot for a midfielder lol 🤔 but at the same time, pep guardiola's squad is always super flexible & adaptable. semenyo might just fill a specific gap in their system, and if he can deliver goals & assists, it's worth the hype 💪 whatever happens, i'll be watching the next match with my city fans 😂
 
Back
Top