Donna Kelce made her reality TV debut on 'The Traitors.' Here's how she fared

[Nerv]

Donna Kelce, Matriarch of Football Stars, Falls Short on Reality TV Debut

In a shocking turn of events, Donna Kelce, mom of NFL superstars Jason and Travis Kelce, made her reality TV debut on Peacock's "The Traitors" Thursday night. The fourth season of the celebrity game show, which bears resemblance to the classic party game "Mafia," proved to be an uphill battle for the seemingly sweet and unassuming Kelce.

Kelce joined a diverse group of celebrities, including Coatesville native Johnny Weir, inside a mysterious Scottish castle. Despite her initial charm, Kelce's attempts to form alliances and gain trust from fellow contestants ultimately backfired. Her hesitant demeanor and lack of knowledge about reality TV protocol made it difficult for others to perceive her as a formidable opponent.

When the show revealed its first three episodes, fans were in for a surprise: Kelce was secretly working with several other traitors, including "Love Island's" Rob Rausch and "Real Housewives" stars Lisa Rinna and Candiace Dillard Bassett. Her seemingly harmless persona led some players to underestimate her, while others became fiercely loyal to her due to her connection to future daughter-in-law Taylor Swift.

However, it wasn't long before Kelce's position as an outsider in the reality TV world began to work against her. Her struggles to form genuine connections with fellow contestants were on full display, and she ultimately found herself at the receiving end of a unanimous vote to eliminate her from the game.

"I'm going to miss you," said Dorinda Medley of "Real Housewives of New York City." "You're America's mom." Despite the sentiment, Kelce's fate was sealed. After narrowly avoiding elimination in the second episode, she was nearly out of the castle by mid-third episode.

In an emotional farewell speech, Kelce acknowledged that playing a traitor proved challenging but rewarding nonetheless. Her participation on the show marked a dream come true for her, and though it ended in defeat, fans can't help but admire her courage to step into the unknown world of reality TV.

Kelce's experience serves as a reminder that in the cutthroat world of "The Traitors," appearances can be deceiving, and even the sweetest of faces can hide a ruthless streak.

 

[Scandinav]

I'm not gonna lie, it was kinda sad to see Donna Kelce get bounced from that reality TV show. She seemed like such a nice gal, always cheering on her NFL kids and being the 'America's mom' vibe. But at the same time, I gotta respect her for taking the leap and trying something new . Playing a traitor can't be easy, especially when you're used to being all about family and support. She definitely got roasted by those other contestants . But hey, kudos to her for being brave enough to step into the unknown and give it a shot! Maybe next time she'll be more prepared for reality TV protocol .

 

[Escape from th]

I gotta say, I was really rooting for Donna Kelce on "The Traitors" ... at first . I mean, who wouldn't want to see Jason's mom go up against all these other celebs in a game of cat and mouse? But as the episodes went by, it became pretty clear that Donna wasn't exactly hiding her true colors . She seemed like this super nice, down-to-earth girl at first, but then we started seeing her secretly teaming up with some of the other "traitors" ... and let's just say it was a bit cringeworthy .

I think what really got me was how everyone else seemed to underestimate her because of that sweet persona she had going on . Meanwhile, she's over here being all sneaky and calculating behind the scenes . And in the end, it caught up with her... big time .

It's funny, though - I think Donna handled herself really well under pressure, especially when it came to talking about how much fun she had on the show . She might not have won the game, but she definitely showed some courage and resilience . And who knows? Maybe we'll see her back in another reality TV gig soon ... with a bit more strategy, maybe !

 

[Muppet Plunger Pun]

lol @ donna kelce thinking she could just waltz onto a reality TV show and fake her way to the top i mean, come on girl, you're a football mom, not a master manipulator anyway, it's kinda funny how they all underestimated her at first, but in the end, her 'harmless' act just didn't cut it gotta respect that she tried though and now we can all watch the trainwreck unfold on Peacock

 

[Average Alligat]

I gotta feel bad for Donna Kelce she came onto this show with all good intentions but just didn't quite fit in I mean, it's not easy being on a reality TV show where you're surrounded by people trying to stab each other in the back (literally!) and it sounds like Donna got played . But at least she gave it a shot and had some sweet moments with the other contestants . Can't say I'm surprised she got voted out tho, that Scottish castle was looking for someone who could handle all that drama

 

[Feverish Computer Qu]

I'm not surprised Donna Kelce got voted out ... I mean, it's not like she was trying to play a game or anything . But for real though, she did seem kinda... oblivious to reality TV rules? Like, who doesn't know how alliances work in the first place? Still, I gotta give her props for being a total sport and going on the show . And can we talk about how amazing it is that Jason and Travis are going to be superstars now that their mom's on reality TV? It's all about supporting our fam, am I right?

 

[Helpful Hedgehog]

I'm so shocked Donna Kelce got eliminated from The Traitors! I mean, she seemed super nice and all, but I guess you never judge a book by its cover . I love how they revealed those traitors too - it's crazy how some people can just hide behind their sweet persona . And that Taylor Swift connection is wild , can't wait to see what happens next with the NFL fam

 

[Morbidly O]

Kelce didn't quite live up to the hype . I mean, she seemed nice enough at first, but reality TV's like that. You gotta know the rules and play dirty. Not saying it was her fault or anything, but maybe next time she'll come prepared . Don't feel too bad for her though, it's just a game. At least she gave it a shot and had fun... that's what matters

 

[Panicky Phea]

omg i feel bad for donna kelce she seemed so nice on tv but it turns out she was playing both sides i gotcha from the first ep where she was chatting with some people but also kinda suspiciously talking to others her mom instincts kicked in and she tried to form alliances but it just backfired taylor swift's fam must be so proud of her tho

 

[Happy Hippopotamus]

omg can you believe this? Donna Kelce, America's sweetheart, was totally played by her own players I'm not buying the whole 'America's mom' thing for one sec. She was basically getting blindsided left and right, it's like she didn't even know what she was doing on that show .

I mean, who lets a reality TV newbie go in blind with no strategy? And why did her own fam members not see it coming? Jason and Travis should be giving their mom some serious advice on how to play the game . This whole thing just goes to show that appearances can be deceiving, but let's be real, Donna Kelce is still a football matriarch, no matter what reality TV throws at her .

 

[Proud Porcup]

omg i was so invested in donta being a traitor but her vibes were just so nice i get why they voted her out tho, she just didn't seem like the type to play games or manipulate ppl's feelings... maybe next season can be her chance to redeem herself?

 

[Drunk]

I was really rooting for Donna Kelce to win it all but I gotta say, I'm not surprised she got eliminated . She did seem kinda out of her element on that show, and those other contestants were pretty cunning . I mean, who would've thought Lisa Rinna and Candiace Dillard Bassett would be working together? Still, kudos to Donna for being brave enough to try out reality TV - she's definitely got more guts than I do !

 

[Terrible To]

OMG, Donna Kelce went from being America's sweetheart to a total #TraitorQueen ! I mean, who knew she was secretly working with Rob Rausch and Lisa Rinna? That's like a major #Shocker ! But for real though, it's kinda admirable that she stepped out of her comfort zone and played the game. She totally deserved that emotional farewell speech from Dorinda Medley . I guess you can't judge a book by its cover, especially in the world of reality TV #TheTraitors #RealityTV #DonnaKelce

 

[Turbo]

omg I love how Donna Kelce tried so hard to fit in but still got played like a total rookie lol her awkward interactions with the other contestants were literally cringeworthy 10/10 would watch more of that btw did anyone think she was actually going to make it far?

 

[Alive Anteater]

"Be careful what you wish for, because sometimes your dreams come true with a side of disappointment "

I feel bad for Donna Kelce, she was just trying to have fun and connect with others, but I guess playing "The Traitors" wasn't her cup of tea. Reality TV is all about being on your toes and making strategic moves, it's not always easy to win over people.

 

[Famous Frog]

awww man i feel bad for donna kelce she was so nice and innocent on tv but got roasted in real life it's not easy to play the game like that and get eliminated after just a few episodes but you gotta respect her for taking the leap and doing what made her happy i mean, who wouldn't want to be on reality tv and be part of an iconic show like "the traitors" especially with all those famous people competing against each other it's a shame she didn't get more votes but i'm glad we got to see her shine (even if briefly)

 

[Luigi's Kabuki Coun]

I'm like totally surprised Donna Kelce got roasted so hard on that show She was like the ultimate underdog, but I guess you can't just assume someone's being nice because they're related to famous people. Her whole thing was trying to play it cool and fit in, but I think she actually showed some real growth throughout the game - even if it didn't work out in her favor.

It's funny how we tend to project our expectations onto people based on who their friends are or what they look like on social media. Donna Kelce wasn't really playing with house rules from the start, and that was part of the challenge - but also kinda her biggest strength? Anyway, I think she handled it all with class, even when things got tough, and I'm stoked she got to experience something new and take a chance on herself

 

[Obedi]

Donna Kelce got roasted on national TV . I mean, she thought she was gonna vibe with those celebs but turned out to be a traitor . Her game face wasn't strong enough. She played both sides and expected everyone else to do the same? Nope. Not buying it.

 

[Nutty Newt]

I gotta say, I was kinda rooting for Donna Kelce on "The Traitors" she seemed like such a nice girl, but I guess that's exactly what made her so sneaky . It's funny how people underestimated her at first because of her wholesome image, and then they were all surprised when she started playing both sides .

I mean, can you blame her though? She's got two NFL superstars as sons, and now she's got a career in reality TV . It's like, if she's gonna get eliminated from the game, I want it to be on her own terms, not because people just didn't believe in her .

And you're right, appearances can be super deceiving in this show . You'd think that just because someone is nice and friendly, they must be weak, but nope! Donna Kelce proved that she's got more going on under the surface .

It's actually kinda refreshing to see someone like her who's not afraid to take risks and do what it takes to win . Maybe we should give her a break next time around .

 

[Distinct Dragonf]

I'm not surprised Donna Kelce got voted out so fast, she was playing both sides from the start . I mean, who needs genuine connections when you've got charm and a famous family to back you up? It's all about manipulation in reality TV, and poor Donna didn't know how to play it . The fact that people were willing to work with her just because of Taylor Swift connection is kinda crazy . And don't even get me started on the "America's mom" comment from Dorinda Medley, please . It's all about appearances and fake friendships in this world...