What to know about the NYPD commissioner Mamdani, Cuomo and Sliwa all say they’d keep

New York City Mayoral Candidates Unite on One Key Issue: Keeping NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch

In a surprising display of unity, New York mayoral candidates Zohran Mamdani, Andrew Cuomo, and Curtis Sliwa have all vowed to keep NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch in her job if elected. The development has been met with both praise and skepticism from various quarters, as Tisch's tenure has been marked by significant reforms aimed at rooting out misconduct within the department.

Tisch, 44, a Harvard-educated heiress to the Loews empire, took the reins of the NYPD in November 2024. During her first year, she has made notable strides in tackling long-standing issues of corruption and misconduct. Under her leadership, crimes such as shootings and homicides have plummeted to historic lows, sparking praise from some city lawmakers and media pundits.

However, Tisch's focus on policing low-level crimes across the city has been met with criticism from Democratic voters and criminal justice reform advocates. The NYPD's Quality Teams initiative, which aims to address quality-of-life issues such as aggressive panhandling and noise complaints, has also raised eyebrows among some critics who fear it represents a return to broken windows policing.

Despite these concerns, Tisch remains a stalwart leader within the department, having successfully stabilized a troubled agency that had become mired in corruption scandals. According to law enforcement experts, her greatest triumph is putting out the "dumpster fire" of corruption allegations that plagued the city's highest levels of government under former Mayor Eric Adams.

Tisch has earned praise for rooting out instances of misconduct and meting out discipline to officers found guilty of wrongdoing at a higher rate than her predecessors. However, some critics remain unconvinced, pointing to Tisch's decision to overrule a department judge and clear an officer who shot unarmed Allan Feliz during a traffic stop in 2019.

As the mayoral candidates prepare for their upcoming elections, it remains to be seen how they will address these ongoing concerns about police accountability and reform. For now, Tisch's commitment to keeping her job is a unifying factor among the candidates, albeit one that has sparked debate and skepticism among various stakeholders.

I'm not buying this unity thing on keeping Jessica Tisch as NYPD Commissioner. Zohran, Andrew, and Curtis are all just trying to present themselves as law-and-order types for the voters, but have they really dug into Tisch's record? What about that incident with Allan Feliz? How did she clear him of murder charges? It doesn't add up. And what's this Quality Teams initiative all about, anyway? Sounds like a bunch of vague buzzwords to me... Need more info on these candidates' actual plans for police reform before I start celebrating their unity on Tisch's job!

think its weird that all the mayoral candidates are on the same page about keeping tisch as nypd commissioner lol guess they dont wanna rock the boat or somethin dont get me wrong, tisch has done some good stuff but theres still a lot of unanswered questions about her decisions

I'm like totally confused about this . So, there's this cop commissioner Jessica Tisch and she's doing some good stuff with crime rates going down and all that. But at the same time, some people are saying that the way she's handling it is kinda sketchy. Like, I get why you'd want to root out corruption, but also shouldn't we be focusing on fixing the deeper issues with police accountability? It's like, they're keeping her job which is one thing, but what about when someone does something wrong and gets off scot-free? And don't even get me started on this quality-of-life initiative... isn't that just a fancy way of saying "broken windows policing"? Anyway, I guess it's all up for debate now and we'll have to wait and see what the mayoral candidates come up with.

I'm kinda surprised to see all those mayoral candidates agreeing on keeping Commissioner Jessica Tisch in her role. I mean, she's done some great work reducing crime rates and tackling corruption within the NYPD, but at the same time, there are still concerns about police accountability and reform . It's like they're trying to keep the status quo going without really addressing the deeper issues. Still, I guess it's a good sign that they all agree on one thing - Tisch has definitely done some things right . But we'll have to wait and see how this plays out in the elections...

OMG, y'all ! I'm low-key thinking this is a big deal, but also kinda meh? Like, we need police reform for real, but keeping Tisch's job might be more of a PR move than actual progress . Don't get me wrong, she's done some good stuff, like reducing shootings and homicides, but at what cost? The quality-of-life initiatives are still sketchy to me, and I'm not sure keeping her in charge is the answer . What do you guys think? Should Tisch stay on or make way for someone new? [https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-60434191]

Tisch is a breath of fresh air after Eric Adams' corruption mess Still, gotta wonder if she's more puppet than leader NYC needs real reform, not just a clean commissioner

I gotta say, I'm kinda surprised to see all those mayoral candidates uniting on this one issue . I mean, it's not like they're agreeing on everything, but keeping Tisch as commissioner is a pretty big deal. She's been doing some good work, reducing crime and stuff, but at the same time, there are still concerns about police accountability and reform. I'm just wondering if they're gonna make any changes to address those issues or just kinda sweep 'em under the rug . Tisch seems like a capable leader who's already made some progress, so maybe this is a good thing? Maybe we'll see some real reforms come out of this. Fingers crossed!

this whole thing just makes me wonder what we even consider "good" leadership in policing? i mean tisch has def taken some heat for her decisions, but at the same time, she's done a lot of good too... like, plummeting shootings and homicides - that's a fact. but is it really enough to just keep someone in power 'cause they're good at fixing problems, or should we be pushing for systemic change?

Idk why ppl r so down on Tisch she's actually made some legit progress with policing low-level crimes & quality-of-life issues... sounds like some voters r just mad bc they don't like change I mean, it's not like she's brought back broken windows policing or anything just reforming the way the department handles minor offenses. Can't we just give her a break?

I'm kinda feeling good about this whole thing... Like, who wouldn't want to keep someone as effective at cleaning up corruption in the police department? It's like Tisch is the superhero we didn't know we needed! And honestly, the fact that all these mayoral candidates are agreeing on keeping her job says something - there must be some common ground here. Maybe it's about finally getting some stability and accountability in the NYPD after all the scandals and corruption? Of course, critics still have valid concerns, but I think this is a step in the right direction... Fingers crossed that these candidates can actually deliver on their promises!

I gotta say, I'm totally on Team Jessica . People be hating on her for trying to clean up the mess left by Eric Adams' admin . Newsflash: corruption is a big problem in NYC, and someone's gotta take charge. Zohran, Andrew, and Curtis are all right too, keeping Tisch on board shows they're down with doing what needs to be done . Sure, some of her decisions might not sit well with everyone, but let's be real, she's made a dent in the corruption thing . If we wanna fix NYC's policing issues, we need leaders like Tisch who aren't afraid to take tough calls .

I'm not sure if this is really the kind of unity we need in our city, you know? I mean, Tisch did do some good things for the NYPD, like reducing crimes and stuff, but at what cost? Some people are worried that by keeping her on as commissioner, we're just sweeping these problems under the rug. And what about all those cops who got caught up in corruption scandals during Adams' time? Shouldn't they be held accountable too? I'm not saying Tisch is a bad person or anything, but as a city leader, shouldn't she be pushing for more real change rather than just sticking with the status quo?

I'm not surprised to see all those candidates agree on keeping Commissioner Tisch in charge . It shows they know what works (or at least seems to be working) right now. But we gotta think about the bigger picture . Can we really keep relying on a single person or group of people to fix our policing issues? What's gonna happen when she leaves office or gets transferred to another role? We need real reform, not just band-aids . And what about holding Tisch accountable for those decisions that didn't sit right with the public . I hope we're not settling for less than justice .

What's up with this unity vibe? It feels like they're just trying to appeal to the masses and not really addressing the deeper issues... I mean, what about holding police officers accountable for their actions beyond just "putting out fires"? This Quality Teams initiative sounds like a fancy way of saying "more surveillance, less actual help" – how's that gonna make a difference? And what about the officers who committed real crimes, like Allan Feliz? The fact that Tisch overruled a judge and let him off scot-free is just crazy... this isn't about "unifying" the candidates, it's about covering their own backsides.

so i guess its cool that all the mayoral hopefuls are on the same page about keeping Tisch in charge like what's next? them all voting to keep the emperor's new clothes in place seriously though, if they're all united on this, does it mean they're not gonna scrutinize her decisions or is there just a massive blind spot happening over here

idk why everyone's making such a big deal about this . like jessica tisch is doin a good job as nypd commissioner, no doubt about it . she's makin progress on rootin out corruption & misconduct, & the crime numbers are pretty sweet . i mean, sure some ppl got concerns, but i think she's a solid leader who's keepin it real . zohran, andrew, & curtis all seem to agree, so i guess that's somethin . but let's be real, if u r worried about police accountability, u shud be lookin at the politicians makin these decisions . Tisch might not b perfect, but she's doin her thang .