Derek Shelton Has A Long Road Ahead Of Him As The Twins Manager

Derek Shelton's Promotion to Twins Manager: A Bleak Road Ahead

Minnesota Twins fans are bracing themselves for a long and arduous journey under new manager Derek Shelton. The club has appointed him, reportedly, after a tumultuous season that saw them finish 70-92.

Shelton's appointment comes with the caveat that he may be walking into a similar trap that plagued his previous stint as Pittsburgh Pirates' manager. During his time in Pittsburgh, Shelton struggled to harness the team's potential due to a lack of depth and quality players on their roster. His tenure ended in May 2025 with the team losing 12 of their last 26 games.

The Twins' current situation is eerily similar to that of the Pirates under Shelton. With a significantly depleted roster, Minnesota will be facing stiff competition from top-tier teams, a challenge that even the most skilled managers can struggle to overcome.

A key factor in determining Shelton's success will be the development and integration of the Twins' promising farm system into the starting lineup. The team has undergone an extensive reshuffle of their roster this offseason, trading away several veterans for prospects, which could either pay off handsomely or prove disastrous if the young guns fail to pan out.

Shelton's appointment comes with a ticking time bomb of uncertainty – how patient will the club be with him as he attempts to navigate the rebuilding process? The Pohlad family's decision to pull the team from sale and then engage in a fire-sale of veteran players has set the stage for Shelton's tenure.

The lack of star power on Minnesota's roster is evident, with only two guaranteed contracts – Pablo López and Byron Buxton. López, who was injured at the trade deadline, is still under contract, but it remains to be seen whether he will remain in Minnesota.

As the Twins embark on this perilous journey under Shelton's leadership, one thing is clear: their success will depend largely on the emergence of their top prospects and how well Shelton can harness them to steer the team towards contention.

I gotta say, I'm not loving this decision by the Pohlad family . They're essentially setting up Shelton for failure by making him rebuild from scratch with a bunch of young players who haven't even proven themselves yet. It's like throwing them into the deep end without a lifeline . And what's with all these trades? I mean, I get it, they wanna shed some dead weight and build for the future, but do they have to give up so many established vets in the process? It's gonna be tough for Shelton to make any progress with such a depleted roster . Still gotta root for him though, he's got a tough road ahead of him

I gotta say, I'm a bit worried about Derek Shelton taking over as Twins manager. He already had issues with depth and quality players in Pittsburgh . Now, they're basically starting from scratch with all these new young guys coming up through the ranks . I think it's gonna be tough for him to turn things around in just one season, especially considering the Pohlad family's moves this offseason . But at the same time, if anyone can do it, it's Shelton! He had some promising stints as a coach before becoming a manager . I'm curious to see how he'll balance the need for patience with the pressure to win sooner rather than later .

The Twins' decision to promote Derek Shelton as manager feels like a gamble . With such a depleted roster, it's gonna be tough for him to make an impact . I think they need to give him more time to work with their farm system and develop these young players . It's all about patience now . The Pohlad family's moves might have set the team up for success, but it also puts Shelton under a lot of pressure . If he can harness the talent from his prospect pool, maybe they'll be able to pull off some surprises . But if things don't go well... it could get ugly .

this is gonna be a looong year for twins fans Shelton gets the job but i mean... what have they got to work with? 70-92 last season was like watching paint dry it's not even close to being competitive the farm system better step up big time or else we're stuck in rebuild mode forever and what's up with the Pohlad family pulling out of sale and then selling off all their vets? that just sets the bar low for Shelton lol what do they expect him to do? magic

I'm low-key worried about Derek Shelton taking over as Twins manager... his track record in Pittsburgh was pretty rough , especially when it comes to making the most of his team's talent. The fact that Minnesota is basically starting from scratch with a depleted roster makes things even tougher for him . They really need those top prospects to pan out ASAP if they wanna make some noise in the league ... but at the same time, Shelton's got a tough job ahead of him trying to navigate all the uncertainty and rebuild the team from scratch . Bring on the drama!

Ugh I'm low-key worried about Derek Shelton taking over as manager for the Twins . They really did tear apart their roster this offseason, it's like they're setting themselves up for failure . And now Shelton's gotta deal with a bunch of young talent that might not be ready to step up just yet... . I mean, can he even fix the farm system they've got? Only time will tell if he's got what it takes to turn this team around

OMG, I'm already feeling the anxiety vibes about Derek Shelton taking over as manager of the Minnesota Twins! The situation sounds super tough with that depleted roster And let's be real, it's not easy for any manager to make a difference when you don't have a solid core team But at the same time, I'm rooting for Shelton and the farm system - it's like they're getting a fresh start If only they could get some stability behind that pitching staff and develop some consistency on offense Fingers crossed Shelton can pull off some magic

I'm not convinced that Shelton is the right guy for this job... I mean, have we seen any stats or interviews where he talks about his strategy? The Twins have a huge payroll, it's weird they'd be rebuilding on a budget like that. What makes us think this farm system will magically produce a star player? It sounds like the team is just handing Shelton a bunch of scraps and hoping for the best...

I'm already sensing a lot of doom and gloom around here . I get that Derek Shelton's in a tough spot with the roster being as thin as it is, but 70-92 was a pretty poor season for the Twins too...not exactly setting a great precedent. And what's up with the Pohlad family's decision to pull the team from sale? Can't we just have some stability around here? Anyway, Shelton's gotta make it work – I'm rooting for him to bring that farm system along and turn this ship around!

omg i'm lowkey skeptical about derek shelton being the twins manager i mean don't get me wrong, he's gotta have some kinda magic up his sleeve 2 or else minnesota fans will be stuck in the cellar for a looong time but seriously tho, their roster is like, woefully underwhelming rn anyways, hope shelton can whip that farm system into shape & get the twins back on track

Dude I gotta say, Shelton getting the job in Minnesota is like throwing a new line into the water - it's gonna take time for it to sink or swim lol The farm system is key here, if they can't make some of these young guys work it's gonna be a long year. And what's up with the Pohlad family's move? Selling off vets for prospects could either pay off big time or leave them in shambles I'm kinda worried about Shelton walking into this same trap he had in Pittsburgh, hope he can learn from his past and make some moves before it's too late